| Platinum | Burnt Honey Dessert Company |
| Gold | Cold Front Gelato |
| Silver | Mizu Real Fruit Ice Cream |
| Bronze | One Cool Cookie |
| Top Pick | Billy Gruff Creamery |
| Top Pick | Dairy Queen |
| Top Pick | Lickety Dripity Food Truck |
| Top Pick | McDonald's |
| Top Pick | Van Isle Poutinerie |
| Top Pick | Waterfront Confections |