| Platinum | Mambo Gourmet Pizza |
| Gold | Bastion Pizza |
| Gold | Paisanos Slice Shop |
| Silver | Red Swan Pizza |
| Bronze | La Stella Trattoria |
| Top Pick | Ali Baba Pizza |
| Top Pick | Departure Bay Pizza |
| Top Pick | Little George's Pizza & Pasta Local Guys |
| Top Pick | Panago Pizza |
| Top Pick | Pizza Mia Nanaimo |