| Platinum | Coastal Boards & Bites |
| Gold | Delicado's |
| Silver | Van Isle Poutinerie |
| Bronze | Gabriel's Gourmet Cafe |
| Top Pick | Black Rabbit |
| Top Pick | Gina's Mexican Cafe |
| Top Pick | Ironworks Crepes |
| Top Pick | Islanders Fresh Authentic Mexican Sauce |
| Top Pick | Kim Key |
| Top Pick | The Modern |