| Platinum | Islanders Fresh Authentic Mexican Sauce |
| Gold | Country Grocer |
| Silver | Nesvog Meats (2014) |
| Bronze | Delicado's |
| Top Pick | Nelies European Deli |
| Top Pick | Nellies Deli |
| Top Pick | Old City Cheese & Market |
| Top Pick | Red's Bakery |
| Top Pick | The Upstairs at Quality Foods |
| Top Pick | Top Notch Burgers |